Good points - a question of semantics?

Posted by Patterson from adsl-63-201-103-106.dsl.lsan03.pacbell.net on August 17, 2001 at 12:19:56:

In Reply to: Well... posted by India Jones on August 17, 2001 at 11:44:08:

I guess from my of view, if I go to a craftsman and say "I like the basic elements of this, but I'd like this added from this source, this from this source, and these specifications which are my own personal elements". Well, to me this sounds like I just designed a jacket, but I've commissioned somebody else to execute the design into a real article - maybe because I don't have the means of skills to actually build the thing. In my mind it is my design, i.e. the person doing the work for me did not come up with it. Sure they may own an element, and it may be a major element. They deserve credit for their part, and I'd not dream of taking that away. Maybe I'm missing something?

Cheers!

Patterson

Follow Ups:

• Hey Patterson, do you cook? Fall Guy 13:19:39 8/17/2001 (6)
  • Yes, I do... Patterson 15:35:11 8/17/2001 (5)
    • And all you need is a can opener and a microwave. ;) Fall Guy 20:12:59 8/17/2001 (4)
      • I always cook from scratch - avoids copyright infringement problems (grin)(nm) Patterson 23:25:37 8/18/2001 (1)
        • You keep livestock?. ;) Fall Guy 23:38:26 8/18/2001 (0)
      • But what if you grate the cheese yourself?! The Big Red 23:51:59 8/17/2001 (1)
        • You have the taken the first step. (nm) Fall Guy 00:08:18 8/18/2001 (0)
• Maybe, maybe not... India Jones 12:53:24 8/17/2001 (2)
  • Yes, but... Patterson 15:37:38 8/17/2001 (1)
    • Or did she... India Jones 10:52:52 8/20/2001 (0)

Post a Followup:

Name:    
E-Mail:  
Subject: 
Comments:

Link URL:   
Link Title: 
Image URL: